An imaginary account of my most unexpected experience
It happened in less than a second.
Zip. Zap.
That was it.
No pain. No warning. No bright tunnel. No celestial music. No distinguished gentleman in white robes asking me to account for my seventy years on Earth.
Frankly, I was disappointed. After all the elaborate arrangements human beings make for arriving in this world, I had expected somewhat better arrangements for leaving it.
I looked around.
The room was familiar. The furniture was familiar. Even the old man lying in the chair looked familiar.
Then I recognised him.
Good heavens! That was me.
I moved closer. There was no breathing. No movement. His face looked surprisingly peaceful.
I tried touching his shoulder. Nothing happened.
“Hello!” I said.
No response.
“Prasad!” I shouted.
Still nothing.
It occurred to me that shouting at myself was unlikely to improve the situation.
I was dead.
What surprised me most was how little had changed. My thoughts were intact. My curiosity was alive. I could see, hear and apparently move about without the inconvenience of using my legs.
Only one thing had disappeared.
My ability to make myself heard.
For a man who had spent much of his life lecturing, writing, advising, arguing and occasionally offering opinions nobody had requested, this was a serious setback.
Then I heard footsteps.
Someone was coming.
I decided to stay. After all, how often does one get an opportunity to attend the discussions that follow one’s own death?
And that too without having to respond.
My wife was the first to discover me.
Her shock and grief moved me. I tried putting an arm around her, but my arm apparently no longer existed in any useful sense.
Soon the children arrived. Telephone calls began. My death had become a major communication event.
WhatsApp groups sprang into action. Messages arrived from people I had not heard from in decades.
“Shocking!”
“Unbelievable!”
“Gone too soon!”
That last one amused me. At seventy, after five stents and a fairly eventful life, I wondered what would have constituted an acceptable departure date.
One gentleman wrote, “He was a man of few words.”
I nearly fell off my invisible chair.
Clearly, we had never met.
Another described me as a perfectionist.
My wife read the message and smiled.
“Perfectionist? You should have seen his study.”
I protested immediately.
“That was organised disorder!”
Nobody listened.
My son recalled how I had always advised him about so many things in life.
“Yes,” said my daughter, “but he never gave up peanuts and burgers.”
My wife joined in.
“He was very particular about punctuality. Especially other people’s.”
Everyone laughed.
I began to suspect that my family had been storing material for this occasion for years.
Then came less comfortable memories: a sharp remark, a postponed promise, a time I had been too busy to listen. I had explanations ready. But they had already moved on to a visit I barely remembered, a gesture of affection I had thought nothing of, and a late-night conversation that had meant far more to them than I ever realised.
Their memories moved between affection and criticism. I could neither interrupt nor correct them.
The next day brought friends and colleagues.
This was particularly interesting.
One friend called me a visionary. Another said I had been difficult to convince.
“Once he made up his mind,” he observed, “you needed extraordinary evidence to change it.”
“Completely unfair!” I protested. Then I paused. Perhaps he had a point.
A colleague recalled my enthusiasm for new ideas.
“He could start three initiatives before breakfast,” she said.
“And ask for progress reports by lunch,” someone added.
There was laughter.
I was irritated. Then came something worse.
“He was always very open to criticism.”
My invisible self nearly exploded.
Had the speaker ever actually tried criticising me?
A younger colleague remembered a meeting in which I had dismissed his proposal rather bluntly. I remembered. The proposal had indeed been weak.
But then he added, “He called me the next morning and helped me rebuild it. I never forgot that.”
I had forgotten it completely.
Another friend recounted a disagreement from twenty years earlier, word for word. I remembered nothing of it.
We clearly do not choose which actions become permanent exhibits in other people’s memories.
Meanwhile, practical questions surfaced. Who would deal with clients? Where were the documents? And how was anyone supposed to find my passwords to close my Facebook account?
Someone asked whether my latest blog had been completed.
“No,” my wife replied. “He was working on another one.”
I felt an unexpected surge of professional anxiety.
There was an unfinished paragraph on my laptop.
And it was quite a good paragraph.
By the third day, I noticed that people rarely spoke about me for long without eventually speaking about themselves.
A friend began reminiscing about a journey we had taken together, but soon the conversation turned to how it had shaped his career. A colleague remembered a piece of advice I had given, only to dwell on the decision she had subsequently made. Even our old disagreements were recalled less for what had passed between us and more for what they had meant to the others.
I found this mildly offensive. Could they not concentrate on me? I was the one who had died.
But gradually something dawned on me.
They were not really discussing my life.
They were discussing the portions of their own lives in which I had appeared.
I was the same person, yet every conversation produced a different Prasad.
The demanding professor. The generous mentor. The impatient colleague. The affectionate father. The argumentative friend. The distracted husband.
Some of these characters were familiar. Others were complete strangers.
Which one was the real me?
I thought I knew who I was: my career, convictions, achievements, failures and carefully cultivated opinions. Yet these people described different individuals.
And strangely, none of them was necessarily wrong.
Perhaps there had never been just one me.
Perhaps I existed in fragments, scattered across the memories of everyone whose life had intersected with mine.
And each fragment belonged as much to them as to me.
Meanwhile, life was continuing with almost insulting efficiency.
Tea was served. Someone complained about traffic. A child laughed at something on a phone. Two relatives discussed an upcoming wedding.
I was astonished.
Had they forgotten that I was dead?
Surely the Earth could have slowed down for a day or two, if only to acknowledge my departure. But apparently, it had other appointments to keep.
Then I noticed my wife reminding someone to eat, my daughter answering a difficult call, my son helping an elderly relative. Nobody was discussing philosophy. They were simply taking care of one another.
Life was not continuing in spite of my departure.
It was continuing because that was what life did.
By now, I had discovered something I desperately wanted to share.
We spend our lives building reputations and worrying about what others think. Yet we have remarkably little control over the versions of ourselves that live in other people’s minds. We cannot edit their memories, and we cannot ensure that our intentions will be remembered alongside our actions.
And perhaps we do not need to.
What a revelation!
So I approached my wife and began explaining.
Nothing.
I tried speaking to my children.
Nothing.
I considered appearing in a dream, but had no idea how that technology worked. I tried dictating a blog through my laptop. The cursor remained motionless.
I had an important insight, but no PowerPoint, no audience and no question-and-answer session.
My frustration was enormous.
Then came another thought.
Why was I so anxious to communicate it?
Hadn’t I spent enough of my life explaining, persuading and offering advice?
Even after death, was I trying to conduct a seminar?
And to whom was I trying to explain my discovery?
To people who would discover their own truths in their own time.
Perhaps the purpose of understanding something was not always to communicate it.
Perhaps understanding could be enough.
On my final evening of observation, a few friends were telling stories about me.
One recalled a hilarious incident involving a missed flight and an airline official. Completely inaccurate! The flight had been rescheduled, and the argument was with a travel agent.
I prepared to intervene.
Then I stopped.
My friends were laughing. My wife was smiling. Someone added a detail that was even more absurd.
And suddenly, I found myself laughing too.
Why did accuracy matter so much to me? Their story was doing something my correction might never have done. It was bringing them together.
For the first time, I felt no urge to set the record straight.
I looked at the people I had loved, irritated, helped and disappointed. I would remain with them in different ways. Eventually, even those memories would fade.
Strangely, that no longer troubled me.
I had arrived without being consulted and spent seventy years trying to understand the world, improve it and occasionally tell it how to behave.
Now I was leaving without having to explain anything.
There was something wonderfully liberating about that.
No more arguments to win. No reputation to protect. Nothing left to prove.
And, most remarkably, no need to have the last word.
Just then, I noticed something unusual.
A little distance away, someone appeared to be standing in a haze. I could not make out the face. There was a strange brightness behind the figure, as though sunlight were trying to tear through a curtain of mist.
I wondered whether I was imagining things.
Then the figure spoke.
“Come in, Dr. Modak. It’s now time to move on.”
I was startled.
Someone could actually see me! And hear me!
I turned towards the figure.
Was that God?
“My God!” I exclaimed.
A little too touchy at times, but overall, I really enjoyed reading this blog. It was engaging and thought-provoking, and it offered plenty to reflect on.
Prasad I was always curious about death, life after it and probably a little far fetched rebirth , but your blog is exactly what I had imagined will eventually happen…. I found your blog very true to the situation I guess is waiting to happen… very nice just my thoughts tooo , YouTube is full of different versions life after death , they say other side of life … many versions but I loved your blog and way u have created situations… well written .. thanks for sharing …
Lovely discourse Prasad…
Excellent thought and writing Dr.Modak. Thanks for sharing.
Foresight of a Gentleman
Wonderfully crafted touching reality in the world of reels.
Insightful Brilliant Prasad very perfectly imagined and quiet Humours too.
Life and Time will go on .😇